How to write a book review that is actually useful
Reviews help readers decide and help authors improve. A few simple habits make yours worth reading.
The QuillBees team
·
·3 min read
When you finish a book, a review is a small gift to the next reader. It does not have to be long or clever. It has to be honest and clear.
Why reviews matter
For readers, reviews are a way to decide whether to buy. For authors and small publishers, they are a lifeline. A book with a few thoughtful reviews is far more likely to be picked up than one with none.
Start with a sentence on what the book is
Say what kind of book it is and what it is about, without spoilers. "A slow, warm novel about three sisters running a family tea shop." The reader should know in one line whether it is the sort of thing they like.
Say what you felt
Did it make you laugh, cry, think or yawn? Which part stayed with you? Your reaction is the most honest information you can give.
Be specific
"I loved it" is nice, but it says little. Why? Was it the characters, the plot, the writing, the setting? "The dialogue felt so natural that I forgot I was reading" tells a reader something real.
The same goes for criticism. "The middle dragged" is more useful than "boring". Point to what did not work, and say why, if you can.
Compare gently
It can help to say who the book is for. "If you liked this author's earlier work, you will probably enjoy this." Or "this is not a fast thriller, so if you want action, look elsewhere."
Avoid spoilers
Do not reveal twists or the ending. If you must discuss something specific, warn readers first.
Be fair
You are reviewing the book, not the author as a person. If you disliked it, say so politely. If it is simply not your kind of book, mention that. A reader who likes slow novels may enjoy what you found slow.
Keep it short enough to read
Three or four short paragraphs are plenty for most reviews. Some of the best are just two or three sentences.
Where to post
- Online bookshops and marketplaces, where buyers will see it.
- Reading communities and book blogs.
- Social media, if you tag the author or publisher.
- Your own blog or newsletter, if you have one.
Posting in more than one place helps the book reach more people.
For authors asking for reviews
Ask politely. Give the reader time. Never ask for only positive reviews, and never pay for them. Readers can usually tell, and many platforms take down reviews that look bought.
A simple template
- What the book is, in one sentence.
- What worked for you.
- What did not.
- Who might enjoy it.
Thank you for reviewing. It matters more than you think.
Liked this post?
Two ways to keep the story going.